FR · Free to Read
15 pointsImmediate access to the complete work without payment or required registration.
- 15: All assessed content is immediately free.
- 8: Most content is free, with material exceptions.
- 0: A paywall, embargo, or mandatory account blocks access.
FP · Free to Publish
15 pointsAuthors can publish without mandatory submission, processing, or publication charges.
- 15: No mandatory author fee.
- 8: Fees exist but a clear, accessible waiver provides a no-cost route.
- 0: Publication requires payment.
OL · Open Licensing
10 pointsReuse rights are clear at both publication and article level.
- 10: A recognized open license is consistently displayed.
- 5–8: Open terms exist but are incomplete or inconsistently displayed.
- 0: Reuse rights are absent or contradictory.
PI · Persistent Identifiers
10 pointsDOIs or comparable durable identifiers support citation and long-term discovery.
- 10: Consistent identifiers for current and archived works.
- 5–8: Consistent current coverage with a documented archive plan.
- 1–4: Limited or irregular coverage.
- 0: No persistent identifiers found.
SC · Scholarly Citations
10 pointsVerifiable evidence shows that published work is being found and cited.
- 8–10: Strong, documented citation presence.
- 4–7: Recurring but developing citation evidence.
- 1–3: Limited verified citations.
- 0: No verifiable evidence supplied or found.
OR · ORCID Adoption
5 pointsORCID iDs support reliable author identification and attribution.
- 5: Collected, displayed, and included in publication metadata.
- 4: Collected and displayed with articles.
- 3: Documented publisher/editor adoption linked to published work.
- 1–2: Limited or inconsistent presence.
- 0: No ORCID adoption found.
AA · Accessible Availability
10 pointsContent is usable across devices and offered in accessible, durable formats.
- 9–10: Strong navigation, readable formats, accessibility support, and no access barriers.
- 5–8: Generally usable with identifiable gaps.
- 1–4: Significant format or usability barriers.
- 0: Content is effectively inaccessible.
SR · Social & Alternative Reach
5 pointsResearch reaches communities beyond conventional scholarly citations.
- 5: Sustained, documented multi-channel engagement.
- 3–4: Active distribution with visible engagement.
- 1–2: Limited or irregular activity.
- 0: No evidence found.
RD · Research Discovery
10 pointsMetadata, indexing, search visibility, and preservation practices help readers find work.
- 9–10: Broad indexing, structured metadata, and preservation.
- 5–8: Multiple working discovery channels with remaining gaps.
- 1–4: Primarily publisher-site discovery.
- 0: No reliable discovery route.
TE · Transparency & Ethics
15 pointsPublic policies explain editorial responsibility, peer review, corrections, conflicts, rights, preservation, and complaints.
- 13–15: Comprehensive, consistent, and easy to locate.
- 8–12: Core policies exist with identifiable omissions.
- 1–7: Minimal or fragmented disclosure.
- 0: Essential publishing practices are not disclosed.